Back to all blogs
Blog Details

Subscribe to Punch! newsletter

Stay in the loop with updates, ideas, and resources.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
5 min read
Published
17 Nov 2026
5 min read
Published
17 Nov 2026

How to Read the Context Behind a Signal-Informed Call

Last updated
17 Nov 2026
AI summary

‍

Contents

Every sales tool can flag when someone starts a new job, and your competitors see the same alert you do. Each rep reads the same fact, writes a version of “congrats on the new role” and hits send. The new hire ends up with a pile of near-identical messages and replies to none of them.

Signal-based cold calling goes wrong between the alert and the call. The signal fires, the emails go out, and nobody asks what the signal means for that company.

Why single buying signals stopped working

New hires, funding rounds, acquisitions and headcount jumps used to be enough to build a campaign on. Now every sales tool tracks them.

Chris Muldoon, our co-founder, said this on a recent episode of our B2B Outbound podcast:

“A lot of these tools have been email automation on steroids. They’re tracking the same six signals, your acquisitions, your headcount, your funding, your new job role, and then they just send out 100,000 emails.”

Ben Robinson, our Chief Commercial Officer, saw it from the buyer’s side.

“Someone just got hired for a new role. They get bombarded with a thousand messages, and a lot of them are coming from these platforms.”

An SDR (sales development representative) who calls on a job change alone is one of dozens of people saying congrats that week. When everyone is pulling from the same data, nobody stands out, and generic intent data makes you invisible next to everyone else sending the same message.

What signal-informed calling means

A signal tells you something happened. Before the call, someone has to work out what it probably means for that company, and signal-based selling depends on getting that right.

Sherlock Holmes worked this way when he first met Watson. He didn’t guess from the tan alone. He put the tan together with the pale wrists, the stiff arm and the military posture, and worked out where Watson had been.

Ben’s team combines data the same way.

“Pulling all these different data points, what we call composite or cluster signals… When we have all these data points aligned, we can say something truly original and stand out.”

Most of that data isn’t in a vendor’s database. As Ben put it, “You can’t just find it on a data platform. You can’t just pull it from a vendor. You have to go scrape it, compile it, augment it, make sure it’s actually usable.”

Where the real context hides

Chris pointed to job descriptions. Plenty of tools will tell you there’s a new marketing director, but few will tell you what the role was hired to fix.

“It’s actually what was in the job description that they hired against, and what the business challenges are they’re trying to solve for.”

Sumair Shakir, one of our go-to-market strategists, looks at when tech was installed. His team checks when a company’s first piece of tech was detected and when a second piece was detected, then counts the days between them. A short gap can mean the company is switching systems. Sumair doesn’t think artificial intelligence (AI) can make that call on its own.

“Are they moving on? Are they using another system for marketing or something else? And AI just doesn’t make that leap, because it’s not trained on that data.”

Take a made-up example.

A logistics firm posts a Head of RevOps (revenue operations) role. The job description talks about consolidating their customer relationship management (CRM) system after a recent acquisition. A tech lookup shows HubSpot has been there since 2022, and Salesforce first showed up eight weeks ago. LinkedIn shows two people from sales ops left in the last quarter.

None of these would justify a call on its own. Together, they suggest a messy CRM migration, a short-handed sales ops team and a new leader who will be judged on fixing both. Now the rep has a reason to call.

Chris added a caveat: “A lot of that is still what it infers is probably going on at the company, versus an exact science of, it is absolutely happening.” So treat your read as a guess and use the call to check it.

How to prioritise which buying signals to act on

You can’t act on every signal. When Sumair picks which ones to use, he’d rather have a few that fit the buyer than a long list.

“In the ideal situation, I want a good filtered list, a hot signal, and then another signal that’s indicating that they’re in market. Right? Like, the pain is fresh.”

A signal that used to carry a whole campaign, like a new hire, now just tells you an account is worth a closer look.

Before he joined Punch!, Sumair ran a campaign for a cybersecurity managed service provider (MSP). Instead of chasing job changes, he looked up each prospect’s DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance) records. He checked whether they had DMARC set up and email security in place, or whether someone could spoof their domain.

The first ten LinkedIn messages all got a reply. One turned into a deal worth ten times the client’s monthly retainer.

You can check a problem like this yourself, and the prospect often hasn’t spotted it yet, so the first message helps them before it asks for anything.

Lookalikes: the go-to signal

A lookalike is a company that closely matches the profile of a customer you’ve already won. When Chris asked Ben and Sumair for their go-to signal, both said lookalikes.

Sumair pointed out that a lookalike is really several signals at once. “You’re matching firmographics, and then you’re matching pain points.” (Firmographics are the company basics, like size, industry and location.)

Ben’s example was a client with around 15 case studies, all with strong metrics. The team targeted the companies that most closely matched those case studies.

Do the same with your own customers. Pull your five best case studies with real numbers and note what those companies had in common in the six months before they bought, such as hiring patterns or tech changes. That list is a signal built on your own wins, and no data vendor can sell it to a competitor.

Who gets a call: scoring and routing your leads

Calls cost the most, because every dial takes SDR time, so not every lead should get one. On most campaigns, Sumair gives every lead one score made up of three parts.

  • Firmographic score: how well the company fits your ideal customer profile (ICP).
  • Signal score: how strong and how fresh the signals are.
  • Contact score: whether you found the main buyer or someone further down the chain.

Sumair explained why hot leads get the phone first.

“It gets prioritised for calling because that’s a cost-heavy channel. So you have to be smart about how you’re deploying that.”

Chris added that the score shouldn’t rely on outbound data alone: “What events you’ve been at, what webinars you’re running, what inbound is coming to your website. It shouldn’t just be outbound versus inbound.” Anything in your CRM should feed the score, which is hard to do without sales and marketing aligned in your CRM.

Sales call preparation: what to say when they pick up

Scoring decides who can get a call. At Punch!, a reply usually decides who gets called first.

When I spoke to Ben last week, he said the SDR picks up the phone when a prospect responds to a campaign and asks for the guide or offer in it. The opener goes something like this:

“Hi Alex, you’ve just responded to us. We’re going to send what you’ve asked for, but I thought it might be easier to have a conversation with you first, and we can talk it through.”

A reply tells you more than any data point. In Ben’s words, “They’re resonating with the problem statements in the messaging. So they’re saying, I’m in market. Yeah, I have that problem.” The prospect has told you what’s wrong, so the call can start there.

The openers to retire

Chris still hears calls that open with a job title and an assumption.

“They’re still going, hey, I noticed you’re Head of Cyber, you must have this challenge. Like, you can do better than that nowadays.”

Ben made the same point about CROs (chief revenue officers). Tell one they might have a sales problem and they’ll roll their eyes. “Obviously I’m a CRO. I’ve always got a sales problem.”

Chris says a rep who gets someone on the line should know what to say and why it matters to that buyer. He thinks the data to back that up has never been better.

A four-line call prep sheet

Before every signal-informed call, the rep should write down four things.

  1. The stack. Which signals fired, and when.
  2. The read. What you think is going on at the business, written as a guess.
  3. The proof. The closest case study you’ve got.
  4. The question. One question that lets them correct your read.

For the logistics firm, say Tom is an SDR at a CRM consultancy called Quillmarsh (made up, before anyone goes looking). His opener might go like this.
‍
“Hi Priya, it’s Tom from Quillmarsh. You asked for our CRM migration checklist yesterday, and I’ll send it over. Quick one first, though. I can see you’ve brought Salesforce in alongside HubSpot and you’re hiring a RevOps lead. We helped a freight firm through the same move last spring, and the reporting gap was what hurt most. Is that where you are, or is the migration itself the headache?”

‍
Tom says what he thinks is going on, backs it with a case study and asks Priya to correct him. If he’s wrong, she’ll say so, and they’re talking, which is where a good discovery call starts.

A great signal doesn’t replace persistence

Chris was clear that a good signal won’t save you from calling back.

“You can have the best signal in the world, the best insight in the world, the best trigger in the world. But the reality is you’ve still got to have a conversation with them. And that might mean you’ve got to make multiple phone calls, multiple attempts.”

He reckons it still takes 10 to 15 tries to reach someone by phone. The signal means you have something worth saying when you do get through.

Sumair thinks every campaign needs LinkedIn, email and calls at the very least, and that you shouldn’t pit them against each other. “They should always be used in concert together.” From what he’s seen, he’d bet SDRs convert ten times more often when they know the context.

What books meetings changes from campaign to campaign. On several of our accounts right now, Ben said, a LinkedIn connection request, two LinkedIn messages and then a phone call is booking the most meetings. Email still goes out on those campaigns, but it isn’t what’s booking them. Run all three and watch which one gets replies from which buyers.

Don’t wait for a reply before you call, either. Once a high-scoring lead has had a few emails and LinkedIn messages, call them.

The part of signal-based cold calling AI can’t do

AI can gather signals and push a message out to LinkedIn or email as soon as one fires. It can’t reliably tell you what a signal means.

Ben put it this way:

“What’s missing is the intuition. The human intuition. That’s where the strategist comes into play. How can we take all the data and actually apply intuition, human thought, to it to make it effective? AI will never have that.”

Chris said the automation is the easy part, “but it’s the actual message beforehand that’s still the human part. The strategy part. That kind of intuition bit.”

So we keep people in charge of it. HotSauce, Punch!’s Unique-to-You (U2U) Signal Intelligence platform, builds and stacks the signals, a strategist works out what they mean, and then one of our SDRs makes the call. 

Every sales tool can flag when someone starts a new job, and your competitors see the same alert you do. Each rep reads the same fact, writes a version of “congrats on the new role” and hits send. The new hire ends up with a pile of near-identical messages and replies to none of them.

Signal-based cold calling goes wrong between the alert and the call. The signal fires, the emails go out, and nobody asks what the signal means for that company.

Why single buying signals stopped working

New hires, funding rounds, acquisitions and headcount jumps used to be enough to build a campaign on. Now every sales tool tracks them.

Chris Muldoon, our co-founder, said this on a recent episode of our B2B Outbound podcast:

“A lot of these tools have been email automation on steroids. They’re tracking the same six signals, your acquisitions, your headcount, your funding, your new job role, and then they just send out 100,000 emails.”

Ben Robinson, our Chief Commercial Officer, saw it from the buyer’s side.

“Someone just got hired for a new role. They get bombarded with a thousand messages, and a lot of them are coming from these platforms.”

An SDR (sales development representative) who calls on a job change alone is one of dozens of people saying congrats that week. When everyone is pulling from the same data, nobody stands out, and generic intent data makes you invisible next to everyone else sending the same message.

What signal-informed calling means

A signal tells you something happened. Before the call, someone has to work out what it probably means for that company, and signal-based selling depends on getting that right.

Sherlock Holmes worked this way when he first met Watson. He didn’t guess from the tan alone. He put the tan together with the pale wrists, the stiff arm and the military posture, and worked out where Watson had been.

Ben’s team combines data the same way.

“Pulling all these different data points, what we call composite or cluster signals… When we have all these data points aligned, we can say something truly original and stand out.”

Most of that data isn’t in a vendor’s database. As Ben put it, “You can’t just find it on a data platform. You can’t just pull it from a vendor. You have to go scrape it, compile it, augment it, make sure it’s actually usable.”

Where the real context hides

Chris pointed to job descriptions. Plenty of tools will tell you there’s a new marketing director, but few will tell you what the role was hired to fix.

“It’s actually what was in the job description that they hired against, and what the business challenges are they’re trying to solve for.”

Sumair Shakir, one of our go-to-market strategists, looks at when tech was installed. His team checks when a company’s first piece of tech was detected and when a second piece was detected, then counts the days between them. A short gap can mean the company is switching systems. Sumair doesn’t think artificial intelligence (AI) can make that call on its own.

“Are they moving on? Are they using another system for marketing or something else? And AI just doesn’t make that leap, because it’s not trained on that data.”

Take a made-up example.

A logistics firm posts a Head of RevOps (revenue operations) role. The job description talks about consolidating their customer relationship management (CRM) system after a recent acquisition. A tech lookup shows HubSpot has been there since 2022, and Salesforce first showed up eight weeks ago. LinkedIn shows two people from sales ops left in the last quarter.

None of these would justify a call on its own. Together, they suggest a messy CRM migration, a short-handed sales ops team and a new leader who will be judged on fixing both. Now the rep has a reason to call.

Chris added a caveat: “A lot of that is still what it infers is probably going on at the company, versus an exact science of, it is absolutely happening.” So treat your read as a guess and use the call to check it.

How to prioritise which buying signals to act on

You can’t act on every signal. When Sumair picks which ones to use, he’d rather have a few that fit the buyer than a long list.

“In the ideal situation, I want a good filtered list, a hot signal, and then another signal that’s indicating that they’re in market. Right? Like, the pain is fresh.”

A signal that used to carry a whole campaign, like a new hire, now just tells you an account is worth a closer look.

Before he joined Punch!, Sumair ran a campaign for a cybersecurity managed service provider (MSP). Instead of chasing job changes, he looked up each prospect’s DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance) records. He checked whether they had DMARC set up and email security in place, or whether someone could spoof their domain.

The first ten LinkedIn messages all got a reply. One turned into a deal worth ten times the client’s monthly retainer.

You can check a problem like this yourself, and the prospect often hasn’t spotted it yet, so the first message helps them before it asks for anything.

Lookalikes: the go-to signal

A lookalike is a company that closely matches the profile of a customer you’ve already won. When Chris asked Ben and Sumair for their go-to signal, both said lookalikes.

Sumair pointed out that a lookalike is really several signals at once. “You’re matching firmographics, and then you’re matching pain points.” (Firmographics are the company basics, like size, industry and location.)

Ben’s example was a client with around 15 case studies, all with strong metrics. The team targeted the companies that most closely matched those case studies.

Do the same with your own customers. Pull your five best case studies with real numbers and note what those companies had in common in the six months before they bought, such as hiring patterns or tech changes. That list is a signal built on your own wins, and no data vendor can sell it to a competitor.

Who gets a call: scoring and routing your leads

Calls cost the most, because every dial takes SDR time, so not every lead should get one. On most campaigns, Sumair gives every lead one score made up of three parts.

  • Firmographic score: how well the company fits your ideal customer profile (ICP).
  • Signal score: how strong and how fresh the signals are.
  • Contact score: whether you found the main buyer or someone further down the chain.

Sumair explained why hot leads get the phone first.

“It gets prioritised for calling because that’s a cost-heavy channel. So you have to be smart about how you’re deploying that.”

Chris added that the score shouldn’t rely on outbound data alone: “What events you’ve been at, what webinars you’re running, what inbound is coming to your website. It shouldn’t just be outbound versus inbound.” Anything in your CRM should feed the score, which is hard to do without sales and marketing aligned in your CRM.

Sales call preparation: what to say when they pick up

Scoring decides who can get a call. At Punch!, a reply usually decides who gets called first.

When I spoke to Ben last week, he said the SDR picks up the phone when a prospect responds to a campaign and asks for the guide or offer in it. The opener goes something like this:

“Hi Alex, you’ve just responded to us. We’re going to send what you’ve asked for, but I thought it might be easier to have a conversation with you first, and we can talk it through.”

A reply tells you more than any data point. In Ben’s words, “They’re resonating with the problem statements in the messaging. So they’re saying, I’m in market. Yeah, I have that problem.” The prospect has told you what’s wrong, so the call can start there.

The openers to retire

Chris still hears calls that open with a job title and an assumption.

“They’re still going, hey, I noticed you’re Head of Cyber, you must have this challenge. Like, you can do better than that nowadays.”

Ben made the same point about CROs (chief revenue officers). Tell one they might have a sales problem and they’ll roll their eyes. “Obviously I’m a CRO. I’ve always got a sales problem.”

Chris says a rep who gets someone on the line should know what to say and why it matters to that buyer. He thinks the data to back that up has never been better.

A four-line call prep sheet

Before every signal-informed call, the rep should write down four things.

  1. The stack. Which signals fired, and when.
  2. The read. What you think is going on at the business, written as a guess.
  3. The proof. The closest case study you’ve got.
  4. The question. One question that lets them correct your read.

For the logistics firm, say Tom is an SDR at a CRM consultancy called Quillmarsh (made up, before anyone goes looking). His opener might go like this.
‍
“Hi Priya, it’s Tom from Quillmarsh. You asked for our CRM migration checklist yesterday, and I’ll send it over. Quick one first, though. I can see you’ve brought Salesforce in alongside HubSpot and you’re hiring a RevOps lead. We helped a freight firm through the same move last spring, and the reporting gap was what hurt most. Is that where you are, or is the migration itself the headache?”

‍
Tom says what he thinks is going on, backs it with a case study and asks Priya to correct him. If he’s wrong, she’ll say so, and they’re talking, which is where a good discovery call starts.

A great signal doesn’t replace persistence

Chris was clear that a good signal won’t save you from calling back.

“You can have the best signal in the world, the best insight in the world, the best trigger in the world. But the reality is you’ve still got to have a conversation with them. And that might mean you’ve got to make multiple phone calls, multiple attempts.”

He reckons it still takes 10 to 15 tries to reach someone by phone. The signal means you have something worth saying when you do get through.

Sumair thinks every campaign needs LinkedIn, email and calls at the very least, and that you shouldn’t pit them against each other. “They should always be used in concert together.” From what he’s seen, he’d bet SDRs convert ten times more often when they know the context.

What books meetings changes from campaign to campaign. On several of our accounts right now, Ben said, a LinkedIn connection request, two LinkedIn messages and then a phone call is booking the most meetings. Email still goes out on those campaigns, but it isn’t what’s booking them. Run all three and watch which one gets replies from which buyers.

Don’t wait for a reply before you call, either. Once a high-scoring lead has had a few emails and LinkedIn messages, call them.

The part of signal-based cold calling AI can’t do

AI can gather signals and push a message out to LinkedIn or email as soon as one fires. It can’t reliably tell you what a signal means.

Ben put it this way:

“What’s missing is the intuition. The human intuition. That’s where the strategist comes into play. How can we take all the data and actually apply intuition, human thought, to it to make it effective? AI will never have that.”

Chris said the automation is the easy part, “but it’s the actual message beforehand that’s still the human part. The strategy part. That kind of intuition bit.”

So we keep people in charge of it. HotSauce, Punch!’s Unique-to-You (U2U) Signal Intelligence platform, builds and stacks the signals, a strategist works out what they mean, and then one of our SDRs makes the call. 

contributors
Expertise
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
other Articles

Continue reading

6
min read
Published
16 Nov 2026
AI Made Outbound Ten Times Faster. That's Now Everyone's Problem
No items found.

AI Made Outbound Ten Times Faster. That's Now Everyone's Problem

Last updated
16 Nov 2026
7
min read
Published
13 Nov 2026
How Punch! Combines Multi Channel Into One Motion
No items found.

How Punch! Combines Multi Channel Into One Motion

Last updated
13 Nov 2026

Subscribe to Punch! newsletter

A monthly dose of Sales Intelligence, delivered straight to your inbox

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.